Prior to 2016-17, the OCCAC had a single all-academic team for the full school year. To be a member of the Academic All-OCCAC team prior to then, a student-athlete must have completed 24 credit hours with at least a 3.30 cumulative GPA.

1994-95

Keith Bradley, Columbus State Community College
Amy Straub, Columbus State Community College
Sharyn Croushore, Columbus State Community College
Brea Corbett, Columbus State Community College
Kori Grant, Columbus State Community College
Kwanita Housman, Columbus State Community College
Melanie Garner, Columbus State Community College
Cheryl Bettinger, Sinclair Community College
Eric Brockert, Sinclair Community College
Chris Jones, Sinclair Community College
John Richardson, Sinclair Community College
Theresa Tanksley, Sinclair Community College
Jason Dunn, Lakeland Community College
Aubrey Peoples, Lakeland Community College
Ryan Brenner, Cuyahoga Community College 
Kazmier Brzozowski, Cuyahoga Community College 
Michelle Mravetz, Cuyahoga Community College 
Melanie Rezac, Cuyahoga Community College 
Misti Sugerik, Cuyahoga Community College 
Joanie Yakunovich, Cuyahoga Community College 
Suleman Al-Ajaji, Cuyahoga Community College 
Sam Cario, Cuyahoga Community College 
Kari Kilmer, Owens Community College 
Leslie Mugg, Owens Community College 
Ashli Barta, Owens Community College 
Julie James, Owens Community College 
Kathy Klosterman, Owens Community College 
Kevin McIlhargey, Owens Community College 
Becky Knannlein, Owens Community College 
Tony Desch, Owens Community College 
Denise Rains, Owens Community College 
Matthew Calmes, Owens Community College